Intelligent Hedge Fund Investing
Successfully Avoiding Pitfalls through Better Risk Evaluation
email editor
Navigate: home > table of contents > The Alternative...
book cover

CHAPTER 7

INTRODUCTION

BIBLIOGRAPHY

ERRATA AND OTHER MATERIAL

< previous | next >

THE ALTERNATIVE SHARPE RATIO
Bernard Lee and Youngju Lee

INTRODUCTION

Lee and Lee apply the tools of portfolio optimization to the problem of selecting a portfolio of hedge funds, i.e., building a fund of funds (“FoF”). Their approach provides an important supplement to the qualitative work of FoF managers in the assessment of individual portfolio managers for possible inclusion in their portfolio of funds.

Their quantitative approach is guided by very practical issues. First, they recognize that elegant mathematical models, while interesting in the abstract, need to be balanced against the need for ease of implementation and interpretation.

Second, they recognize that actual return characteristics of hedge funds, more specifically the negative skewness and excess kurtosis observed empirically, raise questions about the applicability of standard Markowitz mean-variance portfolio optimization.

An added benefit of their approach is the development of an alternative performance ratio that is robust to the departures from normality that lessen the usefulness of the Sharpe Ratio.

Sharpe has argued for some time that the appropriate way to measure the desirability of an asset is by it’s impact on the portfolio’s Sharpe Ratio, not by its stand alone Sharpe Ratio
(See, http://www.stanford.edu/~wfsharpe/art/sr/sr.htm).

Lee and Lee extend this idea to show that the optimal fund of funds portfolio is found by choosing the particular allocations to various funds, such that each individual candidate fund’s Alternative Sharpe Ratio (“ASR”), measured by its contribution to the FoF’s risk, is equal to the FoF’s ASR (in some cases with an added adjustment factor).

Lee and Lee describe a very practical approach to implementing this optimization in a way that recognizes that there is little value to being overly precise, if in practice investors are unlikely to allocate their assets in very tiny bits, maybe no smaller than one percent or one-half of one percent. They are able to illustrate with hedge fund index data that their method can yield better cumulative returns and be more sensitive to exposure to drawdowns accompanying extreme market events, such as the Liquidity Crisis of 1998.

return to top

BIBLIOGRAPHY

  1. Cornish, E. A., and R. A. Fisher, 1937, “Moments and Cumulants in the Specification of Distributions,” Extrait de la Revue de l’Institute International de Statistique 4, 1-14, reprinted in FISHER, R. A., 1950, Contributions to Mathematical Statistics (New York: Wiley).
  2. Fernholz, E. R., 2002, Stochastic Portfolio Theory (Springer-Verlag).
    view at Amazon.com
  3. Fung, W., and D. A. Hsieh, 1999, “Is Mean-Variance Analysis Applicable to Hedge Funds,” Economics Letters 62, 53-58.
    http://www.GloriaMundi.org/picsresources/rb-fh.pdf
  4. Jaschke, S., 2001, “The Cornish-Fisher Expansion in the Context of Delta-Gamma-Normal Approximations,” Working Paper, Weierstrass-Institut für Angewandte Analysis and Stochastik, March.
    http://www.jaschke-net.de/papers/CoFi.pdf
  5. Karatzas, I., and S. Shreve, 1991, Brownian Motion and Stochastic Calculus (2 ed.), (Springer).
    view at Amazon.com
  6. Karatzas, I., and S. Shreve, 1998, Methods of Mathematical Finance, (Springer).
    view at Amazon.com
  7. Markowitz, H. M., 1999, “The Early History of Portfolio Theory: 1600-1960,” Financial Analyst Journal 55(4), 5-16.
  8. Mina, J. and A. Ulmer, 1999, “Delta-Gamma Four Ways,” Technical Paper, RiskMetrics Group, August 1999.
    http://www.GloriaMundi.org/picsresources/jmau.pdf

return to top

ERRATA AND OTHER MATERIAL

  1. Other research by Bernard Lee:
    Lee, B., 2004, "How to Construct Hedge Fund Portfolios and Structured Products Using a Robust Quantitative Framework", presentation notes.
    download (pdf 212K)

return to top

INSIDE REVIEWS PURCHASE

Introduction

Table of Contents

Contributors

"How exciting to read a book that is so timely and practical"
Tanya Styblo Beder, CEO, Tribeca Investments

Publisher: Risk Books
Hardcover: 470 pages
ISBN: 19044339220

Editor: Barry Schachter

www.Amazon.com
(US$ 153.00)

www.Amazon.co.uk
(GBP 85.00)

printable order form
(pdf file 267K)

© 2004 Barry Schachter